HealthLatestNews

Accused of Billing an MRI at 3.5 Times Its Price, Now Trusted to Supply One: Who Signed Off, Health Minister?

Blacklisted under one government, rewarded under the next: the Sunamganj contract exposes a health procurement syndicate that outlives every regime

In 2019, the Anti-Corruption Commission accused a company owned by Md. Aftab Ahmed of buying an MRI machine for Chattogram General Hospital that cost Tk 2.80 crore on the open market but was billed at nearly Tk 9.96 crore. Seven years on, another Aftab-owned firm, HTMS Limited, has been chosen by the Health Ministry to supply an MRI machine to Sunamganj Medical College and Hospital, this time for Tk 17.45 crore.

The MRI lot, along with a Tk 10.50 crore CT scan lot, was awarded through a ministry notification on September 27, the Daily Agamir Somoy reported on November 9. Together they are worth nearly Tk 28 crore.

Same firm, different government

HTMS was blacklisted for 15 years on September 11, 2023, under the Awami League government, for irregularities and fraud in public procurement. Three years later, under the BNP government, the Health Ministry has handed it public money again. The report says the ministry’s own Directorate General of Health Services had also blacklisted the firm on the ACC’s recommendation.

Aftab Ahmed remains an accused in two ACC cases: one over alleged embezzlement of more than Tk 9.15 crore at Chattogram General Hospital, and another over alleged graft of about Tk 13.18 crore in equipment purchases for Shaheed Suhrawardy Medical College Hospital.

Follow the DO letter

At the centre of the deal, the report alleges, is local BNP MP Nurul Islam. He was recently criticised over allegations that he halted development projects worth over a hundred crore taka after demanding a crore taka in extortion. The report says he wrote to the Health Minister to have Dr. Md. Kamruzzaman installed as project director, giving him a grip on some Tk 300 crore in equipment purchases. It alleges the HTMS contract was secured in return for a 10 percent commission of more than Tk 4 crore.

A third lot worth about Tk 13.48 crore went to Advance Biomedic Limited, described in the report as part of the same circle. The same MP’s DO letter allegedly led to a change of superintendent at the 250-bed hospital, where a Tk 4 crore tender was floated on October 29 amid claims of a 20 percent commission deal. The report adds that commissions of 10 to 20 percent for some MPs on hospital equipment supplies have become an “open secret”. The MP did not respond to requests for comment.

The buck stops at the ministry

The project director’s defence is that decisions followed the recommendations of the evaluation committee, the ministry and the DGHS, and that an MP is entitled to send DO letters. He denied any commission or pressure, but said he had no information on how a blacklisted firm passed evaluation. Aftab Ahmed said none of the allegations were correct.

That defence does not clear the ministry; it implicates it. Either the ministry’s committees never checked the blacklist, or they checked and approved the firm anyway. Both failures land on the Health Minister’s desk. TIB’s Dr. Iftekharuzzaman described the award as a clear breach of procurement rules, driven by political influence and collusion.

The questions for the Health Minister are straightforward. Who approved the notification? Was the blacklist checked? Is a lawmaker’s DO letter now enough to hand someone a Tk 300 crore project? And will the contract be suspended pending an independent inquiry?

Until those questions are answered, the Sunamganj MRI machine will stand less as a symbol of better healthcare for the Haor region than as a monument to how little Bangladesh’s health procurement has changed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *